Trying Annie Sloan Chalk Paint And Soft Wax

Dudes and dudettes, I finally tried chalk paint. And yes, I just broke out dudettes. Gutsy move for 2013, eh? Anyway, many of you guys have asked if I’ve given Annie Sloane chalk paint a go, and now that I have, here are the details. First of all, here’s how we used it:

John and I brainstormed a few possibilities for the table that we cut down and the two thrift store chairs that we found in West Virginia (they were $8 each) for a while. Here are a few alternatives that we tossed out there:

  • red chairs with a white table
  • red table with white chairs
  • navy table with red chairs
  • navy table with white chairs
  • one red chair, one navy chair, and a red table

And then we finally landed on something that we thought was interesting enough to make us pull the trigger: wood chairs with red backs and a white table. Of course it was John’s idea (as he is the brains of this operation), although a reader later suggested exactly the same thing, which was a pretty funny “jinx!” moment.

We had a hunch that adding a table and chairs would be something that we’d get some good use out of in there. Sure enough, the day we dragged them into the room to test our theory, this happened.

And this:

And I realized that I even loved Clara’s pj’s layered into the room’s palette. #crazyfabriclady

So after establishing that the table and chairs were a good addition to the room, it was just about getting those chair-backs painted bright red. Our first instinct was to run to the hardware store and grab a $4 test pot of red paint, and get to work sanding and priming. But then I remembered that we had a little sample pot of Annie Sloane chalk paint (everyone at last year’s Haven conference got a bag with a few little pamphlets and samples, one of which was this guy in “Emperor’s Silk”). So I decided to give it a try. I mean I’ve heard it’s really convenient since you don’t have to prep the surface at all (no sanding, no priming, etc).

Update: Chalk paint, although it sounds similar, isn’t the same thing as chalkboard paint (chalk paint is just a flat chalky type of paint, sort of like milk paint or clay paint).

So I brought the chairs out into the sunroom, wiped them down with a liquid deglosser just to be sure they weren’t coated with something weird like oil (you never know with thrift store stuff) and cracked open the red paint. Then I got down to painting the backs of each chair, which took about ten minutes each for each coat.

I used a short handled angled brush (more control) and free-handed things, being careful around the edges to keep them nice and clean (for those who are worried about shaky hands, you can tape off the edges if you’d like). It went on pretty thick even though I did my best not to pile it on (it’s pretty viscous stuff) so there was great coverage and it only took two coats to be completely done. Then I let them dry in the sunroom for a while (it was kinda smelly, so I wouldn’t recommend doing it anywhere that’s not closed off and ventilated – I had the slider wide open in the sunroom while I painted).

But here’s the rub. While chalk paint doesn’t call for any prep before you paint, there’s a step after you paint. I didn’t even realize this going into it, but after a few days of letting them dry in the sunroom I went in to check on them and they felt really dry and chalky. I dragged my finger across the back of one and it actually made a white line (yes, that probably means I left skin cells on the chair, which skeeves me to no end, but the point is that the freshly painted chairs were crazy chalky and dry – not sealed and ready to use at all).

That’s when I learned that Annie Sloane paint gets sealed after the paint dries by applying a coat of Annie Sloane wax over the painted area to seal it and gloss it up for everyday use. Duh. $herdog was not even in on that little fact. The good news is that a friend of mine named Lori (who happens to be Clara’s school friend’s momma) had used Annie Sloane paint and wax on some bookcases in her daughter’s room, so she offered me a few dabs of her wax so I didn’t have to buy a whole tin for two tiny chair backs. Literally, I only needed two dabs, and I used a sock to apply a nice thin coat of wax. Tip: you don’t want to go super thick with the wax or it can have a hard time curing and may stay tacky over time.

It wasn’t really hard or anything, but the thing I still sort of think about is this: if the whole selling point to chalk paint is that there’s no sanding or primer needed, but you have to apply another product afterwards (and buy that as well, unless you have a crafty friend with leftovers) isn’t it sort of the same difference?

I definitely recommend giving it a try if it beckons you, and it didn’t crack and peel or make me hate it or anything, but I’m not convinced that it’s much harder to degloss, prime, and paint (which is what I would have done) instead of deglossing, chalk painting, and waxing. Does that make sense? So my very very honest review is this: I liked chalk paint, but it didn’t change my life. That being said I know there are super crazy chalk paint lovers out there and I totally respect that. Who knows, maybe I’ll use it again and that’s when it’ll change my life. Haha. Ya never know…

In the meantime, there’s one thing I can’t deny. We love our red-backed chairs and we cannot lie.

One more chair pic, just for kicks:

Oh and as for the table, it was stained…

… and peeling down below.

So we gave him a quick sanding…

… followed by a quick primer + paint job. As for the paint specifics, we used semi gloss Benjamin Moore Decorators White in their Advance paint, which is extra durable (we used it on the cabinets in our office when we painted them over a year and a half ago and they’re still taking a licking and ticking like crazy).

As for the placement of the table, we go back and forth between putting it against the wall under the window and pulling it out onto the rug. So we’re living with it both ways to see what ends up being the most functional. We’ll report back as we trial and error our way to a decision. Ha!

This little playroom/big girl room is starting to shape up, right? I mean, we’re only about 35% there, so there’s a ton left on the agenda, but it’s definitely an awesome change to see this room go from Crazy Chaotic Storage Explosion to a room that we can actually all hang out in. Hootie hoo.

What are you guys painting? Have you ever painted just the top or the back of something? Did you eye it or tape it off? Have you tried chalk paint? Did it sweep you off your feet? Does it take a few tries for it to really make you swoon? Or are you a stodgy old traditionalist like me who doesn’t mind primer before instead of waxing after?

Comments

  1. says

    I’ve done more of the reverse- stripping paint off of wood and refinishing it.

    In fact when we lived in Northern Virginia, I used to dream about claiming furniture from the free ads on Craigs List, refinishing (or painting) the pieces, and having a storage place for them.

    I wanted them to have it as a Free and Fantastic Furniture Spot so people who were in need could pick up what they needed.

    This idea wasn’t practical at the time, but maybe one day. You never know where life will lead!

    Here’s to hoping that you enjoy each moment of Atlanta!

  2. Sarah says

    I can’t wait to see and meet y’all tonight at Flor! So glad you saved the best city for last! :)

  3. says

    Those chairs look great! The curtains are stealing the show though… I love them puppies. I know, I know. A guy excited over curtains? My wife would say “your v*gina is hanging out” but seriously those curtains are awesome.

  4. says

    It is so nice to hear about a chalk paint adventure like this. I only read things from fanatics it seems, so I feel like I am missing something. Yet the price and the steps really make me not want to try it. So thanks for this real post. Yet I do still hold out hope that it can change lives based on all of those chalk paint fans out there.

  5. says

    Love watching this room come together…it just seems so FUN! The chairs seem to have an ombre look…is that because of the chalk paint?

  6. says

    Brilliant idea for the two-tone chairs. I was liking the variety the wood added to the room and was interested to see what you’d decide to do for paint. Great job!

  7. says

    First, thanks for the tips on chalk paint. I had long suspected what you said, so I’m glad you were able to try it with a sample and give us the head’s up.

    Second, I love the red-backed chairs! Love. Now, pretty please, consider painting the table navy so the shebang pops. :)

    (And of course, feel free to ignore me, it’s your house after all, but still … pretty please? Navy?)

  8. LeCheech says

    Oh, I actually have a project slotted for this weekend [if I have time] to spray paint bright glossy white on my dresser! I’m leaving the drawers in the finish they’re in. I know that’s been trending lately but I just adore it~!

  9. Samma says

    2 things:
    1) love the red back and natural wood. Is it crazy to think navy on the sides for just a little accent would be fun?
    2) last year when you were looking at the ‘let it go wild’ yard, I suggested BigLots for lilac bushes. Well, they’re back in stock at my local, and I bought 4 for $5. They’re supposed to be frost hardy and be OK in sun or shade, so hoping they work for me. But they also had forsythia (neon yellow firework blooms late winter) and wysteria (big cascading purple white flower cluster on a climbing vine). Any way, it’s a steal of a price so thought I’d pass it along.

  10. Brandy says

    Clara’s new room is really coming together…..it’s so fun and happy! The chairs are awesome…so Christian Louboutin-esque, except on chairs rather than fancy 4 inch stilletos. :)

    Can’t wait to meet you guys tonight! :)

  11. Donna Jean says

    i love the chairs! have you thought about navy chalkboard paint on the to of the table? benjamin morre can tint it almost any color the have. i love that clara has a little cafe table and hubby playing with daughter = #1 dad and total keeper!

  12. Angie says

    Love the chairs and the way the room is coming together, but my favorite part is the picture of John and Clara sitting at the table. Precious!

  13. says

    I have an old Queen Anne style formal china hutch that really doesnt fit with my current decor yet it is a lovely piece. I am planning to use the chalk paint on it to give it a more current look. I know it is still a two step process but I would rather paint and wax than sand, prime and paint. I was happy to read that the waxing process wasn’t horrible for you because my friend had trouble with it, although in my opinion (shh….don’t tell her) she made it more work than it should have been. We will see how it goes. I am cautiously optimistic.