Gina’s Design Dilemma
Gina’s ready to completely overhaul her family room. Here’s her letter:
This is very exciting. I’m so thankful for the chance to work with you! My family room desperately needs your help. It’s large (20′ x 24′) and I’d like to be able to use it more effectively – hopefully for two functions (maybe squeeze in a table and chairs or some sort of other “zone”). My style could be described as sophisticated classic, I like luxe materials here and there (silk lampshades or velvet pillows) and I like comfort, warmth, and rooms that are inviting. I gravitate towards dark wood, simple stripes and florals, natural patterns like leaves/vines, and green, ivory, brown, and ruby red tones. My home is mostly neutral with contrasting accent colors. I don’t like anything too starkly modern or fussy and ornate. We have tentative plans to remove the dark paneling and have the walls sheet-rocked and painted (my brother is law is a carpenter and he’ll help us). What do you think? I would love to get a recommendation for a wall color in anticipation of removing the paneling. I don’t want to paint the brick on the fireplace but here’s what can go: tall dark wooden bookcase, coffee table, bureau under television, and the treadmill. Must stay: bench and louvered cabinet are built in, carpet, sectional sofa, and our flat panel television. Thanks so much! -Gina




Here’s the plan:

And here’s the new layout suggestion:

Now for the mood board breakdown.

1. Our color palette will be full of rich browns, neutrals ranging from tan to cream, and hits of sophisticated pear green and ruby red (which will all look especially delicious with the unpainted brick fireplace and the existing berber carpet). As for the paneling, Gina mentioned that she wants to remove it, add drywall, and paint the room and we couldn’t agree more that an approach like that would really lighten things up and take the room from dark and woodsy to sophisticated and crisp. Honestly if it were us we would just prime and paint the paneling in a rich cream tone (and keep the built-in bench and louvered cabinet since they both provide lots of function and symmetry). In fact Nate Berkus recently primed and painted paneling on an Oprah makeover and it looked just as good as painted drywall if not better (the linear detail created by the grooves in the paneling adds to the texture and sophistication).
But we totally support Gina and her husband if they’d rather remove it all and drywall instead, in which case we still think the same creamy tone will look great around the room to really allow our accent colors to pop while lightening things up by about five hundred percent. Benjamin Moore’s Winter Wheat 232 or Cream Fleece 233 would both be amazing wall color choices and we’d love to see all the trim and those three doors go white for a bit of crisp punctuation in the space.
2. This rich dark wood five drawer chest (on sale!) will provide lots of concealed storage in the place of the shorter and lighter toned dresser that currently lives under the wall mounted TV. We love that it’s a bit taller so it’ll further ground the TV (and make it look less like it’s floating) plus accessorizing the tall chest with some hardcover books in tan, red, green, or brown along with some red vases (like this one) would be the icing on the cake. For extra credit Gina can even get her carpenter/bro-in-law to hinge the top drawer so she can store her TV components in there instead of on top.
And speaking of dark wood furniture, we’d also love to see this elegant and leggy sofa table (on sale!) behind the shorter part of the sectional to provide even more polish from the other side of the room (and serve as a buffet-type space for entertaining at the table). We’d also love a more crisp and elegant floor lamp for the other side of the sectional like this (to replace the existing one for an instant upgrade).
3. One of our favorite ways to define a new zone within a larger multifunctional room is to pop a pendant light in above a large table (around 34″ above the tabletop to be exact). So that’s what we’d love to see Gina do with this gorgeous clean-lined nature-inspired pendant that we dug up for just $129. It’ll really work beautifully with the curtains and the complementary red accent color, and this plug in light may even be able to be converted to a hardwired version and installed by an electrician for a small fee instead of being swagged over the table (which would also look lovely).
4. We opted for a classic oval pedestal table because it will soften things up even more and add to the flow of this large multifunctional room. We also thought that white was the way to go since so many other furnishings will be dark brown (the chest below the TV, the coffee table and the sofa table behind the sectional) so we wanted to break things up and keep everything from feeling too matchy matchy. By placing the table so that half of it can be used by sitting on the built-in bench (which can either be kept if Gina opts to paint the paneling or rebuilt if she opts to remove it) Gina will really optimize this added area that can be used for anything from eating to playing games and even reading the paper on a sunny Sunday morning. Then by introducing three or four of these elegant skirted parson’s chairs (in “harper mocha”) Gina can add more of those sandy neutral tones and create that luxe yet totally comfortable and inviting ambiance that she loves. Oh and that red candle holder on the center of the table is just another way to bring in more of our ruby accent color into the space.
5. We think all the rich neutrals, creams, greens and reds will look great with the unpainted brick fireplace, but a few tweaks will make it feel even more posh. For example, Gina can remove the brass fireplace doors and spray paint them with black heat resistant paint (picked up at Home Depot or Lowe’s) for a totally crisp look that feels instantly updated. And a simple 5″ thick dark wood toned mantel added about 7 bricks above the top of the fireplace doors that wraps around both sides of the fireplace will really add presence and style. Then something like these red flowers can be placed on the mantel in a variety of clean white vases (three on each side of the wraparound mantel would add elegance, texture, and interest).
6. Here are our gorgeous printed leafy green curtains that will add so much high-end ambiance into the room while making the ceilings feel taller and the windows feel bigger. We’d love to see them mounted on long oil-rubbed bronze rods above each window only about an inch below the ceiling and about 15-18″ wide on each side of all of the windows in the room except for the ones that flank the TV (those can be hung just an inch or two past the window frame since Gina wouldn’t want them to interfere with TV watching).
7. Gorgeous high-end looking art like this (here’s one, here’s the other) will add so much style and pop to the entire room, especially when it’s paired with the complementary green printed curtains. We’d love to see them both hanging on the wall behind the long part of the sectional (one centered between the two windows on that wall and one to the right of the first window as you face it (perpendicular to the TV). Once the curtains are hung high and wide there will be just enough space on each of those areas for one of these 20 x 20 prints, so they’ll look perfectly proportioned.
8. This elegant dark wood coffee table will fit right in with the L-shaped sectional while the curves will increase the flow and the glass top will keep things feeling airy and light.
9. We’d love to see a few of these chic pillows (on sale!) tossed on the sectional to break up all that cream fabric and add more posh pattern, interest and color to the entire room.
10. This great 8 x 10 rug will ground the large sectional along with our new dark wood and glass coffee table while tying in with our green, tan, cream and red color scheme. It’ll also help to differentiate the seating area from the dining/game zone that exists behind the sectional.
So there you have it. A multifunctional family room full of sophisticated and classic style. We can’t wait to see what you guys think!
Update: We sadly can no longer find the time to take on client commissioned mood boards (we now whip up general inspiration boards instead) but if we ever reinstate them we’ll make a big announcement!
  Leave a comment
 
 
 
If you enjoyed this post, please leave a comment or subscribe to the feed and get future articles delivered to your feed reader.














































I have been following your blog for sometime. Great advice for Gina. In my case, I am in the process of moving and your drawing reminds me of how things were drawn out on scrap paper or visually in my head. Now I use this room planner site (http://www.highfashionhome.com/)to helps me through the remodeling. Plus the color palette from your previous blog a few days ago. Helped a lot! Thank You…
I have the same rug from Overstock that you used for the room design. Everyone asks me if I got it from Restoration Hardware. I love it but I do recommend a good quality rug pad (I ordered mine from Overstock) as the rug is not very plush – in fact it is quite thin. We have two rooms with the wide plank (knotty pine in our house) paneling. We had it painted for now but will definitely remove it in the future.
Let me just say that you cannot go wrong with that rug choice! I purchased it from Overstock for my house after seeing it on your blog a few months ago, and it is gorgeous!
I just had to chime in and say PAINT THE PANELING :) Our family room has wood paneling in it and there were a few family members who thought it was practically sacrilegious to paint over wood, but we painted it and I still love the color (Behr’s Buffalo Grass). My husband dreams of one day tearing it out and putting up drywall. I say WHY? I love the character. Drywall is BORING:)
I have the exact same sectional, but the opposite. Love it!!!!! I like the red accents. My wall color is Bayou by Pratt & Lambert. I often use red accents but right now I’m on a teal, lime, and black accent theme (in my pillows). Looks great!
Awesome! Can’t wait to see the after photos!
The paneling is the bomb! We’ve been looking around for new digs and honestly paneling is on my “wants” list! I’m a dork, I admit it. I want that extra texture that i’ll of course paint over. And theirs is the real deal, not that cheapo crap that spliters and has gross seams. I say paint it…if you don’t love it you can always drywall later and all you’re out is a couple gallons of paing. LOVE this room…wish I had one just like it.
This has to be one of my favorite mood boards! Love it!
i think this mood board would also look really great if Gina decided to paint the brick fireplace a light color!!! it would draw the focus onto everything else.
I’m so glad you suggested painting the fireplace screen–that brass is killing me! I know it’s making a comeback, but I think for their setting the black you suggested or even better, an oiled bronze finish would look fantastic. I’d love to see some woven items worked into the scheme too–like baskets, or woven trays. The mo’ texture, the mo’ better.
Amen sista. You can never go wrong with woven baskets and oil-rubbed bronze. Yum.
xo,
s
I love this mood board! I really hope that Gina sends after photos your way. Beautiful job!
We were considering demarcating the seating area in our living room with a rug, but we too have carpeting. I’m wary of the rug-over-carpet thing… Any tips on making this work?
We’re big fans of this solution to create a nice floating seating area, sort of like a cozy and casual room within a room. Plus it’s a great way to anchor a sofa or sectional as well as a coffee table or ottoman and any nearby chairs. It really ties a whole seating area together and adds a lot of warm texture underfoot. It always looks great as long as you choose an area rug that will coordinate with your carpeting (but not match it exactly- ideally it’ll be a few shades darker or lighter or a different tone that still works with the carpet). Just check out a bunch of our past mood boards to see which rugs we chose with which carpets to see what floats your boat. Here’s a link to a ton of our past mood boards for easy perusal: http://www.flickr.com/photos/30982446@N02/sets/72157608290321631/
Hope it helps!
xo,
s
I totally think Gina should paint it! If she hates it, she can still rip it out,who knows though she might just LOVE it!
Leslie
What a clever way to use the bench as seating for an added table! That and the pendant light are my favorite things about this board!
I have dark brown paneling in my family room also and I am dying to find a substitute to lighten up the room; no matter how many lights I have on, the room is always dark. When we first painted it yrs ago we used terra cotta tones on the woodwork and bookcases to go with the dark brown paneling. I love the idea of painting the panel in a cream tone, but can anyone suggest a specific paint color they have had good luck with? And will paint adhere to a smooth panel surface?
We like the cream paint color that we recommended in this very post. Check out number one under the mood board for that info. We also like Wishes by Glidden or Mohair by Benjamin Moore. And you can find a “how to paint paneling” tutorial on our How To page under the blog header (in the Painting Projects) section. Good luck!
xo,
s
Hi Sherry! Love this mood board!
Question for you – you mentioned that they should hang their pendant light around 34″ above the tabletop? Is this the general rule of thumb? We bought a similar white pendant light for over our dining table, only thing is, its one of those higher pub tables and with our 7 foot ceilings I’m not sure how to hang it. Thank you!
Erica
Yup, that’s the standard measurement according to most decorators, so you can stick with 34″ for your pub table as well, or go for around 30″ since that might keep the light from looking like it’s riding too high (since the table a bit taller). Hope it helps!
xo,
s
Hi everyone, I’m the homeowner with the design dilemma. I’ve read all of the comments so far (very helpful) and I do have some answers and updates:
* We do indeed plan on painting the paneling, and your positive comments about that reinforce the idea. The paneling is technically “Ponderosa Pine” and is real wood. Once painted I think the ridges will look handsome, like wainscoting, which is a good look for our Cape style home.
* The treadmill has been moved to the basement. My husband now uses it down there.
* My brother-in-law (a carpenter, yay!) has actually rebuilt the bench, which was cracked on top and probably a bit insecure to hold more than one person at a time. It’s a 20 inch deep bench and was raised to a table-appropriate height of 19.5 inches. It’s lovely and we’ll paint it to match the walls.
*My b-i-l has already built the mantel too. It’s held up my black brackets which will match the fireplace screen once we paint that with black heat-resistant paint.
I will send in pics once the whole room is completed. Thanks for all of your comments, and I agree it’s a great design from the Youngsters!
Thanks for stopping in with that info Gina! We’re so excited to see how it all turns out. Good luck and definitely keep us posted!
xo,
s
Sherry,
First off, i want to say that I LOVE your site! this mood board is one of my favorites and Im using it as inspiration for my own living/dining room remodel! I just LOVE the colors and the fact that all the “big stuff” (walls, furnature etc) is so neutral that if you were ever to get sick if the red and green it would be SO EASY to swap those accessories out with new/other colors for a quick, easy and inexpensive change down the road!
Just a quick question regarding the pendant light… Why is it that you chose that particular one? I was looking at lampsplus.com and noticed that there are some lights with the exact same design but are already made to hang (without the pug in) for example: http://www.lampsplus.com/products/Stacy-Garcia-African-Lily-Birch-10-inch-Wide-2-Light-Pendant__17830-J0357.html
Just curious what about the one you chose made you choose it rather than some of the other ones in the same design on lampsplus.com
would the one in the link i posted look good too? I really love this light but would rather be able to just hang it than have a professional come in to wire the one you suggested. I also like the look of the drop down rod rather than the chain (would you still use the chain on the one you suggested if you were going to have a professional wire it or just the cord?)
Thanks so much for your help!!
Jennifer
Thanks so much!
Oh yes, the link you included would look just as good paired with the other items in the mood board- it’s extremely similar (the same exact maker and fabric) so it’s definitely compatible. So if that one tickles your fancy and is easier for you to install then definitely go for it. Hope it helps!
xo,
s