Gina’s Design Dilemma
Gina’s ready to completely overhaul her family room. Here’s her letter:
This is very exciting. I’m so thankful for the chance to work with you! My family room desperately needs your help. It’s large (20′ x 24′) and I’d like to be able to use it more effectively – hopefully for two functions (maybe squeeze in a table and chairs or some sort of other “zone”). My style could be described as sophisticated classic, I like luxe materials here and there (silk lampshades or velvet pillows) and I like comfort, warmth, and rooms that are inviting. I gravitate towards dark wood, simple stripes and florals, natural patterns like leaves/vines, and green, ivory, brown, and ruby red tones. My home is mostly neutral with contrasting accent colors. I don’t like anything too starkly modern or fussy and ornate. We have tentative plans to remove the dark paneling and have the walls sheet-rocked and painted (my brother is law is a carpenter and he’ll help us). What do you think? I would love to get a recommendation for a wall color in anticipation of removing the paneling. I don’t want to paint the brick on the fireplace but here’s what can go: tall dark wooden bookcase, coffee table, bureau under television, and the treadmill. Must stay: bench and louvered cabinet are built in, carpet, sectional sofa, and our flat panel television. Thanks so much! -Gina




Here’s the plan:

And here’s the new layout suggestion:

Now for the mood board breakdown.

1. Our color palette will be full of rich browns, neutrals ranging from tan to cream, and hits of sophisticated pear green and ruby red (which will all look especially delicious with the unpainted brick fireplace and the existing berber carpet). As for the paneling, Gina mentioned that she wants to remove it, add drywall, and paint the room and we couldn’t agree more that an approach like that would really lighten things up and take the room from dark and woodsy to sophisticated and crisp. Honestly if it were us we would just prime and paint the paneling in a rich cream tone (and keep the built-in bench and louvered cabinet since they both provide lots of function and symmetry). In fact Nate Berkus recently primed and painted paneling on an Oprah makeover and it looked just as good as painted drywall if not better (the linear detail created by the grooves in the paneling adds to the texture and sophistication).
But we totally support Gina and her husband if they’d rather remove it all and drywall instead, in which case we still think the same creamy tone will look great around the room to really allow our accent colors to pop while lightening things up by about five hundred percent. Benjamin Moore’s Winter Wheat 232 or Cream Fleece 233 would both be amazing wall color choices and we’d love to see all the trim and those three doors go white for a bit of crisp punctuation in the space.
2. This rich dark wood five drawer chest (on sale!) will provide lots of concealed storage in the place of the shorter and lighter toned dresser that currently lives under the wall mounted TV. We love that it’s a bit taller so it’ll further ground the TV (and make it look less like it’s floating) plus accessorizing the tall chest with some hardcover books in tan, red, green, or brown along with some red vases (like this one) would be the icing on the cake. For extra credit Gina can even get her carpenter/bro-in-law to hinge the top drawer so she can store her TV components in there instead of on top.
And speaking of dark wood furniture, we’d also love to see this elegant and leggy sofa table (on sale!) behind the shorter part of the sectional to provide even more polish from the other side of the room (and serve as a buffet-type space for entertaining at the table). We’d also love a more crisp and elegant floor lamp for the other side of the sectional like this (to replace the existing one for an instant upgrade).
3. One of our favorite ways to define a new zone within a larger multifunctional room is to pop a pendant light in above a large table (around 34″ above the tabletop to be exact). So that’s what we’d love to see Gina do with this gorgeous clean-lined nature-inspired pendant that we dug up for just $129. It’ll really work beautifully with the curtains and the complementary red accent color, and this plug in light may even be able to be converted to a hardwired version and installed by an electrician for a small fee instead of being swagged over the table (which would also look lovely).
4. We opted for a classic oval pedestal table because it will soften things up even more and add to the flow of this large multifunctional room. We also thought that white was the way to go since so many other furnishings will be dark brown (the chest below the TV, the coffee table and the sofa table behind the sectional) so we wanted to break things up and keep everything from feeling too matchy matchy. By placing the table so that half of it can be used by sitting on the built-in bench (which can either be kept if Gina opts to paint the paneling or rebuilt if she opts to remove it) Gina will really optimize this added area that can be used for anything from eating to playing games and even reading the paper on a sunny Sunday morning. Then by introducing three or four of these elegant skirted parson’s chairs (in “harper mocha”) Gina can add more of those sandy neutral tones and create that luxe yet totally comfortable and inviting ambiance that she loves. Oh and that red candle holder on the center of the table is just another way to bring in more of our ruby accent color into the space.
5. We think all the rich neutrals, creams, greens and reds will look great with the unpainted brick fireplace, but a few tweaks will make it feel even more posh. For example, Gina can remove the brass fireplace doors and spray paint them with black heat resistant paint (picked up at Home Depot or Lowe’s) for a totally crisp look that feels instantly updated. And a simple 5″ thick dark wood toned mantel added about 7 bricks above the top of the fireplace doors that wraps around both sides of the fireplace will really add presence and style. Then something like these red flowers can be placed on the mantel in a variety of clean white vases (three on each side of the wraparound mantel would add elegance, texture, and interest).
6. Here are our gorgeous printed leafy green curtains that will add so much high-end ambiance into the room while making the ceilings feel taller and the windows feel bigger. We’d love to see them mounted on long oil-rubbed bronze rods above each window only about an inch below the ceiling and about 15-18″ wide on each side of all of the windows in the room except for the ones that flank the TV (those can be hung just an inch or two past the window frame since Gina wouldn’t want them to interfere with TV watching).
7. Gorgeous high-end looking art like this (here’s one, here’s the other) will add so much style and pop to the entire room, especially when it’s paired with the complementary green printed curtains. We’d love to see them both hanging on the wall behind the long part of the sectional (one centered between the two windows on that wall and one to the right of the first window as you face it (perpendicular to the TV). Once the curtains are hung high and wide there will be just enough space on each of those areas for one of these 20 x 20 prints, so they’ll look perfectly proportioned.
8. This elegant dark wood coffee table will fit right in with the L-shaped sectional while the curves will increase the flow and the glass top will keep things feeling airy and light.
9. We’d love to see a few of these chic pillows (on sale!) tossed on the sectional to break up all that cream fabric and add more posh pattern, interest and color to the entire room.
10. This great 8 x 10 rug will ground the large sectional along with our new dark wood and glass coffee table while tying in with our green, tan, cream and red color scheme. It’ll also help to differentiate the seating area from the dining/game zone that exists behind the sectional.
So there you have it. A multifunctional family room full of sophisticated and classic style. We can’t wait to see what you guys think!
Update: We sadly can no longer find the time to take on client commissioned mood boards (we now whip up general inspiration boards instead) but if we ever reinstate them we’ll make a big announcement!
  Leave a comment
 
 
 
If you enjoyed this post, please leave a comment or subscribe to the feed and get future articles delivered to your feed reader.















































Fantastic! And I have to agree on just painting the paneling…it really makes the walls pop especially with terrific paneling like Gina’s. I have 3 different wall textures going on in my kitchen/dining combo but all painted the same color makes them blend nicely. Love the color selections…another successful mood board; keep up the great work & love your blog!!
Great advise. I really love the pendant lamp you found! And the 5-drawer chest. Simple and classic. Can’t wait to see the after pics!! :)
I totally agree on painting the paneling. You will not be disappoined because just as Sherry said, the lines of the paneling add interest. It provides such a smooth surface that, IMO, it’s much better than drywall. My house was built in 1977 and has paneling in the living/dining room combo. I’ve painted it eggshell white (Swiss Coffee, BM) and it looks fantastic.
I think that’s going to look fabulous. Great job! I can’t wait to see the after.
i really like this mood board–and I totally agree with YHL–keep the wood paneling–the stuff you have is real wood! that adds so much character. if you paint it, and hate it, you can still tear it out later. but if you paint it and love it, save the money for the new decor!
I love the color palette! My current colors are ivory, green, and brown, and I’ve been looking to add another color.
And I agree about painting the wood paneling. It’ll still have the same effect, but it’ll be cheaper!
also, i can even envision a mantel about the fireplace that is painted the same color as the table–that same white. i think that would also look really good, and bring that white color over to that side of the room in another wood piece….kind of nice balance. just another idea!
I agree on the paneling. We primed and painted ours at our old home. We used Bin primer which is shellac based to prevent knots from bleeding through the new paint and It worked like a charm ( a little smelly though). I know it is not the greenest idea but it beats getting rid of all the existing panelling. I love the mood board you guys planned the colors are great. The only other thing I would suggest is painting out the fireplace screen black – to get rid of the 70′s look (again we did this at our current home) be sure to use high heat spray paint.
altho i’m not major decorator like you youngsters are, i did want to mention that i recently painted my brick wall that’s the same color as in Gina’s house. we’ve been in our house six years and i’ve always been too afraid to paint it, fearing that old worry of “once you paint it you can never undo it” thing. so i never put brush to brick. recently however, i got a bee in my bonnet and told the hubby that if he wouldn’t kill me, could i paint the brick? he was not thrilled about the idea but didn’t stop me either so i took that to mean that yes NOW i can paint the brick. yay me!
anyway, i painted it and i think it turned out beautifully. it brightened up my space, making it more up-to-date and modern. i bought Valspar paint in an eggshell (SailCloth–a gorgeous creamy white) and did half paint half water to the mixture and did a white wash. it turned out so well, that i wish i had more bricks to paint. :)
you can see the post and extra photos by visiting my post if you want.
bylgdblog.blogspot.com/2010/02/family-room-make-over.html
your blog is so wonderful, i love all your ideas and it helps me figure out what looks i love. thank you! love it!
laurie eller
Great items for this room makeover.
FYI, I love that you chose that rug from Overstock…I own it! It’s a great rug and definitely looks more expensive than the $455 price tag (which includes shipping, FYI). It “shed” for a few weeks and needed frequent vacuuming, but that’s normal, and it’s a gorgeous, muted, lovely rug that goes well with contemporary and traditional design.
Hey Rachel & Megan,
Thanks for the tip on the rug and the coffee table. It’s always great to hear from people who own the items in our mood boards so they come “pre-approved.” Sweet!
xo,
s
We have this coffee table and we love it! I love the curtains too…great picks :-)
Every single room in my 1925 duplex has paneling, and it is ALL painted, and I love it! I just did my dining room in Glidden’s Antique Beige and my den in Glidden’s Pebble Gray and it covered beautifully. I used Valspar in another room and wasn’t as pleased with the coverage.
I <3 painted paneling.
Love this mood board! Great colors! Good work (as usual, of course!)
= )
Beautiful! Just beautiful! Simply stunning, once again!
I have those curtains! I ordered them a month ago, and put them in my dining room and they are even more gorgeous in person!! She will love them!
Thanks for the firsthand curtain review Kristen! It’s always nice to hear from people who own items from our mood boards just to be sure that they’re as amazing in person as they look online.
xo,
s
Beautiful moodboard! Can’t wait to see the ‘afters’.
As for the paneling, I would agree that painting (while a huge pain!), can end up with beautiful results, as well. When we bought our house, the whole finished basement had that same kind of knotty pine paneling. We painted it all white, and absolutely love it!
If you’d like to see the before & after photos, feel free to visit the post on my blog:
http://thisfreshfossil.blogspot.com/2009/11/basement-before-after.html
Love the ideas on this makeover. I recently painted solid wood paneling in my dining room. It turned out beautifully. Saved a ton!
Lisa
What a great space to reimagine!
I spend a summer painting apartment complexes one year and the paint over paneling didn’t really turn out very well, but you’re very likely far more skilled than me. :)
And the dark wood coffee table? Gorgeous.
One of my favorite mood boards! I love the pendant light and the red flowers.
Another pro-panel-painting vote, too. I painted my parents’ family room paneling and it was simple, made a HUGE difference, and added some vertical interest to the room.
I agree, paint the paneling, it will give the room so much style. For the small price of spray paint, black on the fireplace screen will make a big difference in the room. Love the built ins, wish I had some in my house.
Love all your ideas, I can’t wait to see the room.
I love the mood board you created! I agree about painting the paneling. I think it would look great painted & add texture as you said. The pillow & curtain panels from Ballard Designs are great! I’m positive this room is going to look fantastic!!!
I also agree that you should definitely paint the paneling!! We have real wood paneling on our walls as well, that have been painted a creamy off white color -and it really does add interest to the walls. Similar to the look that wainscotting or bead board adds to walls!
I am about to buy a house – and there is a gigantic living room in the house just exploding with built in shelves! I noticed there was a set of built in shelves in Gina’s room – would you recommend painting the shelves a different color than the wall? How would you go about painting the shelves?
Your advice would be appreciated!!
Sarah
Those shelves aren’t actually built in (that’s just a big bookcase Gina added but will be removing to accommodate the table). However, it’s totally a great move to paint shelves the trim color for a bit of pop. If you want them to blend in, keep them the wall tone but if you want to accent them you can paint or paper the back of them or even paint the shelves to set them apart. Hope it helps!
xo,
s
I’m actually envious of the paneling and the bench! It will look so pretty and bring subtle texture into the room without being overwhelming. I say go for it!!
I agree with everyone else – keep the paneling! It adds a lot of character and will look great in a lighter color. This mood board is awesome! Great job Sherry. Mood boards are my favorite type of posts! Its so amazing to see how to pull a room together – this room will have tons of style when completed!
I have to pipe up and say paint the paneling! I did in my old house and really loved it. The knotty pine was nearly an inch thick and I didn’t want to go through the work to rip it out. Primed it and painted it and ended up with a lovely office.
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_5eAsh0MA3MA/SZjh1hjvo0I/AAAAAAAAAgk/V5Yslsu1lZ4/s1600-h/offce.JPG
Try painting the paneling! My mom and dad’s house was built in 1982 and has icky, icky faux-wood paneling. Painting the paneling resulted in a much more contemporary look. They used Sherwin-Williams Macadamia in their living room and it has held up well.
This is why you guys are da bomb (if anyone even says that anymore!) This room would have most people scratching their heads as to what to do … but it’s definitely gonna be a wow! once these lucky folks do what you suggested. So great work! I’m stealing these color ideas!
Our entire first floor is covered in paneling. Our concern is that painting it is a temporary solution. We are planning on putting up drywall and taking care of updating the electrical in the process. To those who have painted the paneling, are you planning on replacing it eventually or will you just leave it there?
Well done! I LOVE the idea of making a seating zone out of the built-in bench. Does it need a cushion to bring it up a little more towards table height, or is it good to go?
jbhat
Good question! Maybe Gina can weigh in on that, but a soft cushion in a similar tone to the slipcovered chairs would be nice. I guess we’ll have to wait for the after pics to see how it all turns out!
xo,
s
My parents painted over the paneling in several rooms of their house. It looks great and they don’t plan to re-drywall.
We too painted our very own paneling in the den and don’t plan to remove it or drywall. Hope it helps!
xo,
s
LOVE what you came up with. I was intimidated when I saw the before pics and read the description of what Gina wanted but you guys nailed it! Great job!
I painted the paneling in my huge family room, by myself, I might add. I have never regretted it at all. It makes my fireplace, which is similar to the one in this room, look so much better. I get complements on it from everyone and feel pretty smug that my husband love it and says I was right to want it painted!
Gorgeous design! I’d just like to share an easy, money-saving suggestion that also would also add texture and a personal touch. Instead of dropping $160 plus shipping for Z Gallerie’s Coral on Red prints, why not handcraft DIY coral shadow boxes? I’ve done the project myself with wonderful results, netting two gorgeous pieces for under $50. I posted details on my blog (I’m just getting started and find constant inspiration from YHL). I think the project might be a perfect fit, swapping out the any red fabric for the canvas color I used. Check it out @ http://choosemychoice.blogspot.com/2010/03/show-and-tell-custom-shadowboxes.html
Oh Gina, don’t take the paneling down! Paint it, but don’t tear it down. It’s so lovely!
Gina is lucky to have such a large space!
I bet that new table will be the fav. spot in the room, what a great way to use the built-in bench. The round coffee table is a great choice–round tables work really well with sectionals, I think.
I just wanted to comment on Meredith’s questions– that you do NOT have to remove paneling (or drywall!) in order to update all the electrical in a house. In fact, it’s complete overkill to do so. A trained electrician can work behind the existing drywall or paneling. It’s a totally feasible long-term solution to keep the paneling and still update the electrical.
This moodboard makes me want to redone my entire living room – to look just like this. Fantastic job Sherry, and I can’t wait to see the results!
I would kill to have beautiful honey-colored knotty paneling like that, as it is.
I urge them to carefully remove the panels and sell them to someone who wants them. Then put up something that’s meant to be painted, like drywall.
Great mood board and I agree with everyone else – paint the paneling. Sherry, the drapes are gorgeous! In the first picture it looks like the fireplace hearth goes all the way to the wall. That might interfere with the drop of the panel on that side of the window closest to the fireplace. How do you compensate for that area? Also, did you recommend that Gina keep the roman shades on the window over her built in bench or do you think that window would look better without a treatment?
Can’t wait to see the after pictures!
Hey Denise,
Good questions! We told Gina that she could either keep her existing shades (and rehang them at the higher curtain height) or bring in some textured bamboo blinds – so it will be interesting to see where she ends up. And when it comes to that curtain panel near the hearth, for balance we think it still needs to be floor length, it might just come forward a bit and drape from the hearth down to the floor. Should still look great. Hope it helps!
xo,
s
We too painted real wood paneling in our den a soft white color, over oil-based primer, and it was gorgeous for about 6 months. Agreed that it has much more texture and interest than drywall in the right space. When winter rolled around though, the wood contracted and the paint separated at all of the places where the sections of paneling meet. It makes sense – wood contracts and expands with the weather after all, but we even had caulked those seams before painting! No one else has mentioned this problem with painted paneling. Anyone else experienced it? Did we miss a step? Any ideas for what to do before we repaint to keep it from happening again?
Oh man that sucks. We didn’t have real paneling so we didn’t have that issue. I’m wondering if oil-based primer would block enough expansion somehow to help your paint stick more effectively. That was our approach but again we weren’t dealing with real wood. Anyone else have words of wisdom?
xo,
s
I second the idea about painting the paneling, rather than drywalling.
I’ve seen some fabulous before & after pics of such work and it’s been impressive for the bang for the buck value.
They could always paint one wall of the paneling and live with it for a couple days and see what they think. No harm, no foul. It’d sure be an easier way to go than the drywall and I think it’d look even nicer, because there’d be that hint of texture and lines underneath for added eye appeal, rather than just “same ole, same ole” drywall.
I could personally see painting the fireplace, too, but to each her own. That could always be done much later, if they decide, after all their other changes, that they want to give it a go.
Hoping to see some “after” photos down the road. Love those.
Elise, our farmhouse has 100 year old horizontal wood plank walls in every room. The boards expand in the summer when the humidity level is higher and contract in the winter months when our indoor air is dryer. The ideal time of year to paint real wood paneling is during the winter months when the seams between each board are the most visible. Also, it helps to keep the humidity level in your house during the winter between 30 and 50 percent with the ideal level being about 45 percent. This is especially important if you have a lot of natural wood in your home. Hope this is helpful.
Thanks so much for the tip Denise! We hope it helps Elise with her paneling issues.
xo,
s
I love the colors, and I absolutely adore the curtains and rug! Can’t wait for the after photos!
we live in a 50s ranch house that had a family room with dark wood paneling. Rather than remove it, we painted it as others have said. I was surprised at how much I like how it looks painted. Kind of a beadboard effect with the vertical lines.
Good luck!! this looks like s fun makeover : )
Denise – Thank you! That’s great advice. Our house (and paneling) are approaching a century old as well – so perhaps more finicky than the “younger” stuff.
Ooooh, I hope you decide to just paint the paneling. What a great look, with so much character.
I’m wondering where they’re going to move their treadmill. I can’t think of a nice place to put ours, because truthfully they always look ugly. Does Gina have another room to move it to? Have you guys done a room that designed around one? Maybe a screen? Thanks! I love the mood board.
Hey Maryanne,
Gina did mention that she had another room in mind for her treadmill but we’re not sure what it is (maybe a guest bedroom or a home office with some extra space?). As for obscuring them, we have seen people use screens as you mentioned or also hang a curtained wall in one corner of a space to tuck the treadmill behind. It’s quite a large machine to hide so it’ll never be invisible but obscuring it with a wooden screen or some breezy fabric is worth a try. Hope it helps!
xo,
s
I love what you came up with for this room – it is going to look so great! Also, I just have to chime in on the painted paneling issue. We have a fully paneled basement, and we painted it Glidden Wishes (since I liked the look in John & Sherry’s den) and I love it. I also painted faux wood paneling in my kitchen with BM Decorator’s White (also per Sherry’s suggestion) and it looks great. Both have held up well in winter and summer, and I live in New England where the weather shifts dramatically between the seasons. I would really encourage Gina to paint a wall of the paneling first, and see how she likes it. I think that it will add great texture to the walls, but still be nice and neutral because of the color. If she hates it, she can still pull the paneling down and drywall it instead.
Great job! And interesting and really helpful comments on being careful when painting wood paneling in a cold location. We’re working right now on our cottage, which has half faux wood paneling and half knotty pine. It’s in upstate New York and will definitely have (drastic!) temperature changes through the seasons, so I’m glad we’re painting it during the winter! Your site is such a great source of advice – thanks!!