Diane’s Design Dilemma
Diane’s living/dining room is bursting with boundless potential. Here’s her letter:
I came across your website last year and just got around to signing up for some design help. What convinced me is reading that you both lived in NYC – so you know what it’s like to live in a small apartment! So here’s my living room. Did I mention that it is also my dining room? The hard part is that although it’s a good size, it’s been hard for me to figure out the perfect layout since there is a lot of unusable space — 2 doors into the room (from foyer and also french doors into kitchen/dining alcove), a wall with windows and a heater in front of them and then the wall with with fireplace and built-in bookcases. My style is traditional with a modern flair – I really like the things you’ve done in your house. I should mention that I’m in my early 40′s, so I don’t want anything too young looking and I don’t mind spending a bit more money to get some quality pieces. I just bought the couch, the mirror and the pictures (although the mirror and pictures can be used elsewhere and the lamp will be going in my bedroom). I love geometric shapes. I’m open to color/paint suggestions, but would like to keep it somewhat muted vs. bright. Also, please excuse the mess – wow, in person I never realized what a storage facility this place is. I’m cleaning up, RIGHT NOW. Thanks and have a great weekend. -Diane




This multitasking space is primed for a major makeover. Here’s the plan:

And now for the mood board breakdown.
1. Our color palette was inspired by the new cream sofa and the blue botanicals on the floor in the last photo, so we instantly knew a soft blue, cream, tan and chocolate brown scheme with crisp pops of white would enliven the entire space. Bringing in just a dab of celadon green will inject even more of that fresh yet oh so soothing vibe for a room that will totally work overtime for Diane. We also love the soft cream tone already on the walls, so we’d actually suggest sticking with that wall color and adding accents and furnishings to build on that gorgeous foundation.
As for the floor plan, we’d love to see two smaller matching accent chairs flanking the fireplace and facing the sofa to create a nice balanced seating area in the “living” part of the room. Then we’ suggest a larger dining table floating in front of the window (so that when you walk in from those french doors, a proper dining area is right there to greet you). This floating dining table can also serve as a workspace, and bringing in a smaller rug in the living area will give the dining space a bit more visual room.
Then on the wall to the right of the sofa (as you face it) a handsome media stand will balance the dark wood table on the other side of the space and add some functional concealed storage to the room. The TV will still be easily viewed from the sofa and even from the two chairs flanking the fireplace, but it will also be visible from the dining table just in case Diane is using it as a work surface and wants to watch her favorite show while she toils away.
2. Not only were we inspired by Diane’s cream sofa and her blue botanicals. We also noticed that she mentioned loving geometric shapes, and we immediately wanted to bring in a slew of interesting lines with two of these gorgeous octagonal floor mirrors. One on each side of the fireplace behind each of the matching chairs will appear to expand the space while adding balance and a ton of geometric style- and we must admit that we’re crazy about these gorgeous accessories!
3. With mirrors on either side of the fireplace, we thought both of Diane’s existing botanicals would look amazing above the mantel- so we’d love to see them leaning up there for a chic yet casual vibe. To complete the fresh new fireplace look, we’d love to see these sconces (on sale!) switched in for the existing ones. The subtle crystal detail and sleek metal surround will instantly update the entire room. We also needed something for above the sofa, so we looked high and low for a piece that would complement the blue botanicals without feeling too matchy-matchy. Enter this amazing soft blue canvas (on sale!) stage left. With delicate birds on a branch, it will perfectly complement the existing botanicals that will hang across the room. Delicious. Oh and being certain not to hang it too high will keep everything looking approachable and inviting (the base of the canvas should only be about a foot above the top of the sofa).
4. With an accent chair on either side of the fireplace (angled in a bit towards the center of the room), a coffee table will really connect the seating area and add function to the entire space. We adored this cream colored beauty (on sale!) because it not only works seamlessly with our palate but it introduces another great geometric element (a circle pattern) to the space for texture and interest to spare.
5. Rich creamy curtains hung high and wide above the dining room window will add instant polish and welcoming style, and we loved the subtle diamond detail (more shapes!) in these gorgeous cream taffeta panels from Overstock.
6. Here are the chairs that we’d love to see on either side of the fireplace to add a bit of sophisticated celedon to our palette. Their small footprint makes them perfect for a multifunctional room, and they’re still plush and comfortable even though they don’t take up much visual space.
7. Here’s the lovely leggy dining table that will float in front of the window to create a proper dining space that feels airy and open since it won’t be pressed up against the wall. Thanks to a smaller living room rug (and eliminating the pink armchair), there will be plenty of room to move around and it will feel more spacious in there in no time.
8. For an abundance of bookcase decorating ideas, Diane can check out this old post of ours, but we’d also suggest keeping the color palette of the items on those built-ins pretty refined (so the room feels airy and serene). Some pops of crisp white will look lovely, and we thought these clever faux books would be a great place to store anything from remote controls to DVDs and other objects that always look better when they’re tucked away. A few hits of soft blue or green (vases, candlesticks, hardcover books) would also look fabulous against the soft cream backdrop.
9. Here’s the gorgeous wool rug (for just $179) that will really make the room. It’ll work beautifully with the existing sofa as well as the new celedon chairs by the fire and even the cream coffee table. The soft stripes and plush texture will also add a lot of welcoming warmth, and by intentionally selecting a 5 x 8 rug, the front legs of the sofa can rest on the rug (as well as the coffee table, which will really connect the seating area) while the dining space suddenly feels a lot more spacious.
10. These pretty woven rattan chairs will add texture and style to the dining area and work gorgeously with the leggy and elegant table that we selected for that corner of the room. There are also optional cream cushions for added comfort so Diane really can have it all in her multifunctional space. The dark color is luxe and rich, and of course it ties in with the dining table but it will also be reflected across the room in this classic and clean media cabinet that we’d love to see to the right of the sofa as you face it. This will add some much needed concealed storage as well as a hit of deep toned wood on the other side of the room for a balanced and cohesive effect.
11. Speaking of cohesive, we found another decorative white object that would look lovely on those built-in bookcases on either side of the fireplace. This piece also has a removable lid so it can offer even more clever storage while adding a bit of visual interest. Oh and speaking of the fireplace, we also dug up this great fireplace screen that will work really well with our light and fresh scheme (thanks to the brushed nickel material and some nice clean lines).
12. We searched far and wide for a pillow that would do our art and our palette justice when placed on the existing cream sofa… and we immediately swooned when we saw this lovely pillow with the perfect colors and design to add even more to this makeover. One on either side of the sofa will really tie everything together in a major way. And we love that the leafy branches and flower pattern subtly tie into both the botanicals and the canvas art that we dug up.
13. Last but not least, although we’d love to see Diane’s two blue botanicals leaning next to each other on the mantel, we also like a bit of asymmetry and a dash of sparkle, and these three candlesticks are just the thing. Two on one side while one remains on the other will create a nice asymmetrical yet totally stylish focal point in the room (and complement the gleaming new sconces), especially with those amazing octagonal mirrors on either side of the mantel.
Oh and speaking of sparkle, we love the existing table lamp (that Diane mentioned might move into the bedroom), so we think leaving it on the side table will really add a lot to the room once the art is hung and the mirrors are up and everything starts feeling more polished and streamlined. Diane will be amazed at how much balance will be added to the space, so a single table lamp will really work without looking out of place at all!
So there you have it. A living/dining room full of soft and inviting style. We can’t wait to see what you guys think- especially you Diane!
Update: We sadly can no longer find the time to take on client commissioned mood boards (we now whip up general inspiration boards instead) but if we ever reinstate them we’ll make a big announcement!
  Comment
 
 
If you enjoyed this post, please leave a comment or subscribe to the feed and get future articles delivered to your feed reader.




































I love this room – such a great space to start with! I have the white faux croc books and love them. They look chic and double as storage so you can’t go wrong! Can’t wait to see the finished room!
So beautiful!
Hi Sherry (& John),
Thanks so much for all the wonderful tips and ideas. I’ve already ordered a number of things and I think you have a great idea on your hands for people like me who are decorating-challenged but don’t want to invest a ton of money hiring an expensive designer. I’ll definitely be forwarding pictures of my bedroom shortly – can’t wait to see what you do with that!
Thanks again and have a great day.
- Diane
Oh, that room has fabulous “bones”!!! And I love all your ideas….it’s going to look terrific!
Suzanne
Sherry & John, I just found your site two days ago and I’m in love! I love the work you’ve done. Your ideas are going to look beautiful in Diane’s LR/DR.
Diane,
Love the table lamp that is already in your space. The room is great already. You will have to send Sherry and John updated pictures once you redo the room.
Fabulous as usual!!! Love the art, colors, everything!!
I love mirrors — nice touch!
I notice you mention a media stand in item 1 and item 10, yet there isn’t one depicted in the mood board. I am curious as to why. I did click the link to see the one recommended and love it.
I am also bummed that the fireplace screen isn’t pictured. Evidently it is sold out as the link is an “object not found” so it is hard to visualise it.
I definitely agree that removing and replacing the two side chairs is going to be the most immediate improvement to the feel of the room.
I envy Diane’s built-in shelves.
Hey Rowan,
Alas, some mood boards just can’t accommodate every single furniture piece or accessory that we recommend for the space without feeling a bit too cluttered and chaotic for our tastes. This is why we link to a few supplemental pieces and try to include the most important items that will establish our color scheme and encapsulate the big picture in the mood board. You can easily check out any item that we link to even if it’s not on the mood board by reading through our explanation, and we’re so sorry that the fireplace screen sold out (it was just a clean-lined brushed nickel one) but we hold our mood boards for a few days before publishing them so that our clients have first dibs on everything that we find. Hope it helps to explain our process! Stay tuned for the after pics…
xoxo,
Sherry
Diane your space is already to die for (literally… I would kill for an apartment like that!!) but Sherry and John’s ideas are great as always!
What an amazing space!! I can’t wait to see the afters. I adore that sofa. What I wouldn’t do to have a sofa like that and keep it looking nice with kids living here. Hah! Maybe in 20 years…
This mood board is so classy! Good luck Diane! My favorite part is the idea for the side chairs to face the couch with the awesome mirrors behind.
This mood board is beautiful and is perfect for the space. I live in an appartment and can’t paint the walls which are cream. Which of the drape colors from overstock do you think would look best with cream walls and a chocolate brown sofa?
Hey Iris,
The “bisquit” colored curtains would look lovely with cream walls and a chocolate brown sofa. Feel free to send us before and after pics! Curtains can really make the room. Happy hanging!
xoxo,
Sherry
I can’t wait to see the finished product!! It looks gorgeous!! :)
Wonderful selections and color palette. I think that the addition of the Tempo Velvet Pillow will help make the Kristen pillow pop even more against the cream sofa.
Is the “crystal” table lamp next to the sofa the one going in the bedroom? Too bad if it is because I would look wonderful in that room and be a perfect compliment to the sconces you specified.
Love it! I actually have the Ballard Design canvas of the bird for sale on Craigslist for $60.00. (I’m in the Bay Area). And I just bought that rug at Overstock 2 weeks ago – I absolutely love it! Great quality rug.
Absolutely lovely choices, especially the mirrors, pillow, botanical print, and that pillow. Fabulous.
This mood board is beautiful. Everyday I’m amazed at what you come up with. I have a similar color scheme going on in my living room, but need to paint my existing mirror frame which is a yucky gold. Would you go with a semi gloss? It’s either going white or espresso, not sure yet.
Hey Tressa,
I would definitely go with semi-gloss paint for a nice wipe-able finish that gleams. We painted a gross faux-bronze mirror we snagged on sale at HomeGoods a while back and we can’t believe the difference a crisp coat of white paint (or espresso paint for that matter) can make! Happy painting…
xoxo,
Sherry
Gorgeous mood board as always! Combined with the great bones of Diane’s living room it will be simply stunning.
For some reason, I usually love every accessory you guys choose! This time, it’s the croc books and the mariposa box, i think i need one for my kitchen counter. beautiful job as always!
speaking of curtains… when are you guys going to update your den pics in the house tour with the new curtains? :)
Good point Amy! Nothing gets by you, huh? It’s totally on our list, so stay tuned…
xoxo,
Sherry
I love the print and pillow!
This room is so pretty to start with! I sure hope she sends pictures when she gets some of the mood board suggestions in place.
Wow, this is fabulous and exactly my style! Absolutely love it. I have been eyeing those Kristen pillows at C&B for a while… just gorgeous. As always, great work.
I love those faux books and the coffee table! How do u guys manage to find these? I guess you two are great at visualizing what pieces go with what.
Beautiful mood board!
This might be my favorite board yet. I am in LOVE with her couch and those gorgeous pillows.
Lovely, lovely, luv-uh-lee :) Those curtains are so great! Wonderful work on this one, guys.
Question – I was mentally adding up costs as I read through this mood board and thought, “Yeesh. This is some serious coin”. I know Diane specifically mentioned that she was completely willing to buy some more expensive items, but it got me wondering about budget for redesigns. I know budgets vary widely, but humor me here :) In a living room where you’re only keeping, say, a sofa, a few end tables, and a lamp, what do you all think is the lowest reasonable budget to really get someone’s room swanked into Young House Love condition? From the rug all the way to the white ceramic animals on the bookshelf – how much do you think is without a doubt necessary to swankify a room?
Good question Jacci, and I think the answer will surprise you. In a good way. We’ve swankified a room with $200 at Ikea, right down the the art and the accessories (you can check out Carrie’s living and dining room makeover here). Major room makeovers can come in a variety of budgets and you’d be surprised how many fabulous yet-oh-so-affordable items are out there just waiting to be discovered. When it comes to our mood boards, our clients set the budget (each person fills out a thorough questionnaire when they submit their dilemma) and while some people request a certain brand name or level of quality and have saved up money to put towards their room, others are down for the cheapest way to majorly transform their space and they don’t mind Ikea or Walmart). Of course it’s lots of fun to have around 5K at our disposal, but we love a challenge so some of our favorite suggestions are pieces that can be purchased or modified for under $50!
In general, the room that you describe sounds like it could be completely transformed with new curtains, an area rug, some accessories, maybe some art, and perhaps a few matching table lamps. Those items can easily be secured for under $700 and can definitely be found for half of that or even less if we let our fingers do the walking online. And if our client is willing to take on some great DIY projects like painting what she has or picking up something birch and staining it herself we could probably do the whole thing on $200 (yes, for a rug, two lamps, curtains, art, and accessories like pillows and vases and candlesticks). With creativity, enthusiasm and a little elbow grease, we have found that anything is possible when it comes to sprucing up a space! In fact, stay tuned for a seriously cheap-o dining room makeover (yes, we got after pics!!!) coming later this week. Wahoo!
xoxo,
Sherry
I really like this mood board and I hope she send in some after pictures. The colors are so soothing and I think it will look gorgeous in that room. Great job.
I came across your website a few weeks ago after reading your article in a recent magazine. I absolutely love the ideas you shared for this living room! These are my absolute favorite colors and I enjoy using these colors in living areas and bedrooms. I really think the colors that you choose gives the room a classic look while providing a mood of tranquility/relaxation. I enjoy interior decorating as a hobby and enjoy visiting your site. Keep up the great work!!!!
I keep meaning to say that I like that you changed how you do your mood boards and you now send them to your clients first. It was always disappointing when someone ordered a mood board from y’all and by the time they went to order things you suggested other readers may have beat them to it and the item was sold out. Great choice in now sending the mood boards to the clients first!
I would just like to say that you guys are totally inspirational! Your designs are gorgeous, and your budgets are realistic. My fave designer, Sarah Richardson once said: It’s not a challenge to re-do a room when the budget is endless. It is the mark of a truly good designer to be able to work within a small budget and still make a room look beautiful.
Your designs embody that spirit. GREAT job!
I love the tonal neutral palette you used. I know this room is going to turn out fantastic. Great mood broad! Hope to see the finished product!
Thanks for the budget info, guys! :)
Another lovely room. What I really like in this one is that it was a classic room with good bones and you stayed true to those features. The throw pillow is gorgeous.
Beautiful mood board! I love her 2 existing botanical prints. Does anyone know where they came from? Thanks!
Good question! They are gorgeous aren’t they? We’ve seen some similar versions on art.com or all posters.com so you might want to check there. Hope it helps!
xo,
s